Top Ten Tuesday: Übermenschen!

This week’s Top Ten Tuesday challenge at The Broke and the Bookish is to name our Top Ten All Time Favorite Characters In Books. I wanted to participate in this week’s Top Ten Tuesday, but I didn’t want to break from the A-to-Z Blogging Challenge. The problem? It’s U day! U for crying out loud! And so I had to come up with a phrase that encapsulated the theme of this week’s challenge using the letter U. English failed me, but thankfully, German came to the rescue! It’s not perfect, but I think “Übermenschen” will do the job. The word is actually the plural form of the word Übermensch which Neitzche used to describe the kind of person that he thought should be the goal of humanity: the superior-man, or superman. Clearly, this is not the sense I intend it–I simply mean it to refer to great fictional people. So here they are–my all-time favorite (at least right now) book characters:

  • Sherlock Holmes: The super sleuth himself. I am very partial to detective fiction, and Holmes is the epitome of the genre. I like the way Conan Doyle wrote him as flawed due to his dispassionate pursuit of logical precision. He cares little for the feelings of other–except perhaps Watson.
  • Harry Potter: The hero of the series. I like many of the Potter characters, but it’s really all about Harry. And, again, he’s a hero with blemishes. He might be kind, brave, and loyal, but he’s a real teen, and he can be angry, jealous, and petty.
  • Death: In his Discworld series, Terry Pratchett gives Death a new lease of life! He appears as the stereotypical Grim Reaper, but he is not just a symbol. He speaks in all caps, he can only be seen by wizards, and he has a daughter. If you’ve never read any Discworld, and you want to try one out, read MORT.
  • Draco Malfoy: Malfoy is a nasty piece of work. But I like that of all the nasty pieces of work in the Potter series, he has limits. In fact, given the things he won’t do toward the end of the series, you can’t help wondering how much of his behavior was peer pressure, and deep down he really knows Harry was on the right side. Perhaps a little too optimistic?
  • Jeeves: Bertie Wooster’s indefatigable and unassailable butler in P.G. Wodehouse’s famous series. Two characters couldn’t contrast more vividly than Jeeves and Wooster, and I like the fact that Jeeves manages to steer a course between respectful obedience and fatherly guidance of his flighty master.
  • Samwise Gamgee: Frodo’s faithful friend. He’s not the sharpest knife in the drawer, and he’s by no means the bravest or best of the Fellowship. But his loyalty to Frodo and his unswerving friendship, even in the darkest times, makes him stand out.
  • Deryn Sharp: Co-hero of Scott Westerfeld’s LEVIATHAN series. She’s a Scottish lass who wants to fight in the British army during Westerfeld’s alternative World War I, but to do so she has to disguise herself as a boy. I like the way she passes herself as a midshipman, able to do all the guy stuff with the other guys, and yet manages to retain a sense of her femininity. Very well written.
  • Grimble: I talked about Grimble on this blog a few weeks ago (he was “G” in the A-to-Z Blog Challenge). He was one of the first book characters to capture my imagination, so Grimble will always have a place on lists like these.
  • James Bond: Yes, the book Bond, not the movie Bond. I enjoy the Bond movies, but the character in the books is a lot less of the “ladies’ man” “shoot-first-ask-questions-later” figure we see in many of the movies. He is far more reflective, a lot more vulnerable, and much more human. Yes, he has an eye for the ladies, but he’s nowhere near the womanizer you see on the big screen.
  • Marvin the Paranoid Android: If you’re not familiar with Douglas Adams’s HITCHHIKER’S GUIDE TO THE GALAXY series, this character’s name itself should intrigue. He is indeed a paranoid android. A robot who constantly moans about having a “brain the size of a planet” and yet he’s asked to do menial jobs. “Life! Don’t talk to me about life…” Totally brilliant!

Don’t forget to visit The Broke and the Bookish to see what others think, and to participate!

 

cds

Colin D. Smith, writer of blogs and fiction of various sizes.

You may also like...

21 Responses

  1. Julie Dao says:

    Samwise Gamgee is my favorite character in the entire LOTR series. I don’t think anyone has ever written loyalty and a good heart better than Tolkien.

  2. Elodie says:

    Your list makes me want to add several books to my TBR and I think I will 😀 Thanks for sharing, Colin! (and clever way to get the U post :D)

  3. Daisy Carter says:

    What a great list! I hesitate to admit this, especially here, but I’ve never read a Sherlock Holmes story. *ducks tomatoes* I’ve seen all the old black-and-whites; my grandfather insisted I watch them as a little girl. But I haven’t read the books. I think I might have to add one to my TBR, especially since I’ve been in a mystery mood lately.

    Can you recommend the best book to start? Any other mysteries (perhaps more modern ones) that are good ‘beginning mystery reader’ books? Nothing too graphically violent, please. My stomach can’t handle those.

    • cds says:

      Thanks, Daisy. I think I’ve recovered from your confession. Let me advise you: get immediate help in the form of some good Holmes education! 😉 First, if you want to watch Holmes stories, look for the 80s TV series starring Jeremy Brett as Holmes. These are set in Victorian London, and are for the most part very faithful to the original stories. Brett was an excellent Holmes. For a modern rendition of Holmes, nothing can beat the recent BBC re-imagining starring Benedict Cumberbatch as Holmes.

      Conan Doyle only wrote 4 novel-length Holmes stories: A STUDY IN SCARLET, THE SIGN OF FOUR, THE HOUND OF THE BASKERVILLES, and THE VALLEY OF FEAR. Of these, the first is a must–it tells how Holmes and Watson meet, and you get your first taste of Holmes’s methodology. The rest of the Holmes canon exists in the form of short stories Conan Doyle wrote that were collected into volumes (THE ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES, THE RETURN OF SHERLOCK HOLMES, etc.). There are over 50 short stories, varying in quality. Among my favorites are “The Dancing Men,” “The Speckled Band,” and “The Second Stain.” In some stories, Holmes has the task of identifying the culprit and bringing him/her down. In others the culprit is clear, and the puzzle is in how to catch him or her (a bit like my Jasper Quinn story yesterday). Then there are others where Holmes has to find something of great value (e.g., “The Blue Carbuncle” or “The Naval Treaty”).

      So, to begin your Holmes treatment, if you’re not ready for a novel, pick up THE ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES and start with some of the short stories in there. If you get a taste for the character, pick up A STUDY IN SCARLET. One of the great things about Holmes is that the stories are now all public domain, so you can get them for free online, or for very little in a printed edition.

      As for modern mysteries, it depends what your taste is. My wife enjoys Donna Andrews’s series of mystery novels. I haven’t read them yet (I need to), but she describes them as humorous cozy mysteries. If you’re looking for an easy modern introduction to the genre, that might be just your ticket.

      I hope this is helpful to you, Daisy, and I hope you end up joining the legions of Holmes admirers. 🙂

      • Daisy Carter says:

        Thank you, Colin! So glad we’re still blog friends despite my shortcomings! 🙂

        I’ve not heard of Donna Andrews, will definitely look her up. And as for Sherlock Holmes, have no fear! I was at a bookstore perusing last night and happened across a bargain-book edition of “The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.” Picked it up and will start it as soon as I finish the book I’m reading!

        Thank you for all the insight and direction – helped a ton!

  4. Jaime says:

    I love Samwise Gamgee. He’s such a great character! I did the A to Z + Top Ten Tuesday mashup today too. I went with ‘Unforgettable Characters’ (but thought of ‘unbeatable’ too). But hey, German works too 🙂 You’ve got a great mix of characters here. Mine mostly feel like the same old ones I keep raving about all the time (Katniss, Peeta, Hermione,…). This was a fun topic, though 🙂

    • cds says:

      I, too, felt like I was re-using characters I’ve raved about before. And that makes sense–if you really connect with a character, that’s not going to change in six months. With this list, I tried to focus on characters that either really stuck in my head, or that are well-rounded with good and bad elements. It is a fun topic, and a good challenge to constantly pay attention to characters and how they’re written.

      I’ll be over in a minute to check your post out… 🙂

  5. Laura says:

    I’ve only read a couple Bond books and seen just a couple of the older movies, but I would argue with you on the womanizer bit – I remember a sex scene in “Casino Royale” being described as having “the sweet tang of rape.” Ha! Glad we’re not in *that* era anymore. And I’m extremely glad the movies aren’t in that era anymore, either.

    That “Leviathan” series sounds cool – I will add it to my list!

    • cds says:

      Thanks for the comment, Laura. You’re right, there is an element of that in the Bond books–the movies got that from *somewhere*–but I would say it’s not nearly as pronounced as in the movies. I’ve read all 14 original Fleming novels (though it has been a few years). The movies suggest that Bond invented casual sex, which is not the impression I get from the books. Like I said, he’s “a lot less of the ladies’ man”–not that he’s “not at all a ladies man.” And we have moved on (thankfully) in the representation of relationships in books and movies over the last 50-60 years. My main point is that the movie Bond of all but the Daniel Craig movies can seem a little cold and lacking in nuance, whereas the books present a much more flawed and human character. IMO, anyway. 🙂

      The LEVIATHAN series is totally cool, and I heartily and unreservedly recommend it. 🙂

  6. Colonialist says:

    Sharp and Grimble are the only ones with which I am unfamiliar. I like your choices.
    You think YOU had a problem with U? I fat-headedly set myself the task not only of coming up with a topic with the letter, but writing a rhyme on it with all first lines starting with the letter. Sheer lunacy.

    • cds says:

      Thanks, Colonialist! I highly recommend the LEVIATHAN series. Great characters and a really good story. I’ll have to check out your “U” topic. 🙂

  7. I think Robert Downey Jr. is doing quite a great job as Sherlock Holmes, don’t you think?
    Speaking of superman, I can’t wait for Man of Steel — Christopher Nolan’s superman movie!

    • cds says:

      I’ve only seen the first of the two Robert Downey Jr. Holmes movies, and he is good… but Brett and Cumberbatch absolutely nail the character for me.

      Nolan’s Superman movie will be one to watch, indeed! 🙂

  8. Alex says:

    Your characterization of Jasper *really* makes sense now. And I need to get through HHGTTG someday because I like humorous speculative fiction.

    • cds says:

      I’m treading a careful line with Jasper. I don’t want him to be a teenage Sherlock, but I certainly want him to echo Sherlock to some extent. You should be able to see Holmes in him, but also for him to be his own character.

      The first three HHGTTG books are the best IMO.

  9. J.W. Alden says:

    What an awesome list! Most of those characters have a special place in my heart, from Samwise to Marvin. The characters we learn to love as readers definitely help shape the worlds we create as writers. Great post!

    J.W.

    • cds says:

      Thanks, J.W. I can certainly say the way these characters were written has taught me a lot about character development in my own writing.

  1. January 12, 2022

    3sessions

Share your thoughts... I usually reply!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.