Who Review: The Bells of Saint John
Part two of Doctor Who, Series 7, the 50th anniversary year, kicked off with a tale of Wi-Fi paranoia. The world is connected by invisible lines of data traveling from computers, smart phones, cameras, and all sorts of devices to and from servers across the world. What if a malevolent power could infiltrate those data streams and use it to capture human minds, uploading people into a cloud from which it can feed? That’s the crisis facing the world when the Doctor is awoken by the Bells of Saint John, alerting him to the location of Clara Oswald. But finding her means having to save the world, too.
SPOILER ALERT!! My comments may (and likely will) contain spoilers for those that haven’t seen the episode. If you want to stay spoiler-free, please watch the story before you continue reading!
It seems that after the events of “The Snowmen,” the Doctor has joined a thirteenth century monastery, secluded, trying to figure out where the mysterious Clara–the girl who died twice–might be. The “Bells of Saint John” that alert him is, in fact, the ringing of the TARDIS telephone (“Saint John” being a reference to the “Saint John’s Ambulance” badge on the front). That telephone is not supposed to work, and on the other end of the line is Clara, thinking she’s calling tech support because she’s lost internet connectivity. This brings the Doctor back (or forward) to 21st century London, where he connects (or re-connects) with Clara.
Overall, I enjoyed the episode. Yes, the idea that human minds can be beamed across Wi-Fi is a bit of a stretch, but let’s face it–the main story here is Clara. The anti-gravity motorcycle ride up the building was also, perhaps, a bit too much, but, again, all good Doctor Who fun.
I thought the story was a good introduction to 21st century Clara. She has that feisty independence that seems to be a requirement for Doctor Who female companions these days, but she’s not as sassy as Amy was–which I like. I also like that Clara’s not trying to upstage the Doctor, which I felt happened too often with Amy. I wasn’t a big fan of Amy Pond (if you can’t tell), and I think Clara is a marked improvement.
I probably missed a ton of things, but I don’t know that this episode gave many clues to the Clara mystery, other than establishing a connection with the Claras we’ve already met (RYCBAR as the household Wi-Fi password–“Run You Clever Boy and Remember,” a combination of phrases used by future Clara and Victorian Clara). I think there’s some laying of clues that will come to fruition later. The Great Intelligence makes a return appearance, showing he/it survived “The Snowmen,” and seemingly survived this encounter with the Doctor. He may well be prove to be an important part of this season–and possibly has something to do with the Clara mystery? And I’m still convinced that the bow tie the Doctor uses is either one of the Second Doctor’s bow ties, or one very much like it. Compare pictures and you’ll see what I mean!
As I said, it was a fun episode, not the greatest, but certainly not the worst. I like Clara, and there’s a good chemistry between her and the Doctor. Being the 50th anniversary year, I expect the truth behind Clara to be something big and special.
If you saw this episode, please share your thoughts: the comments are open for as-spoilery-as-you-want discussion (though I encourage you to restrict your comments to this particular episode–I’ll be reviewing the others over the coming days)!
It’s interesting to hear you say you didn’t like Amy as I didn’t either and much prefer this one. I liked this episode as I think the idea of being controlled in this way taps into a common paranoia about technology. It wasn’t the best episode in my opinion but as a way of establishing a bond between them was great. I like how she comes across as just as intelligent as the doctor in a way.
It was an interesting idea. I don’t know that Wi-Fi is *that* ubiquitous yet–though I do think there will come a time when it’s like radio. But the concept of someone malevolent taking control of the various data streams is quite scary. There is a good chemistry between the Doctor and Clara, and she does seem quite able to keep up with him. Is she the perfect companion? And if so, is that a clue…? 🙂
It took a few episodes for me to get to the best of part 2 IMO. I did like the idea of the Wi-fi. Way to turn something well used in the 21st century into something horrific and mind-sucking. Loved that.
I do like Clara. I’ve liked all his companions in their own way but I have my favourites, Martha being at the top but I can now see Clara competing for that number one spot. She’s one of the most down-to-earth companions I’ve seen so far. I like that she shows a lot of fear in their adventures but she keeps going. She can’t help that curiosity. I know I wouldn’t! ^^
There is certainly that fear and determination in Clara that’s good to see in a companion. I hope she sticks around after this season. I’m afraid once the mystery of Clara has been solved/revealed, she’ll be gone, and that’d be a shame.
Looking forward to your comments when I get to what you consider the best of part 2, Robin! 😀
Just a couple more to go! =D
I agree with you about Amy. I didn’t like Amy. Rory, however, was much nicer! I liked this episode, especially the motorbike ride. It wasn’t too OTT for me. It wasn’t the best I’ve seen, but I thought it was a good opening episode.
Yes, Rory was, IMO, a much better companion than Amy. The motorbike ride was fun, but I still can’t imagine how he rode up the side of the building and then broke through the window. Definitely one of the better “opening” stories… though technically it wasn’t the first in the series… but you know what I mean. 🙂