What’s Up Wednesday
It’s time for another catch-up on life as we hit the middle of the week, known as “What’s Up Wednesday.” This blog meme is the brainchild of Jaime Morrow and Erin Funk. If you want to know how to participate, and see a list of current participants, visit Jaime’s blog.
What I’m Reading
I finished THE MADMAN’S DAUGHTER by Megan Shepherd, and I must say, it did improve a bit for me after about half-way through, when the danger and mystery started to ramp up. The romance still annoyed me, but not because of the romance itself. It took getting to the end for me to concede that there was a plot point to the love triangle, at least somewhat of a plot point. I think it’s the way Juliet responded to her feelings that I didn’t like. Juliet comes across to me as a emotionally scarred, analytical kind of girl, and hardly the kind to get all gushy about boys. IMO, her feelings could have been handled with a lot more nuance, and frankly more sophistication. There are a couple of other things that made me shake my head, but I’ll talk about those in a moment. As I said, the novel did get better, or maybe I just got used to the style–possibly a bit of both. When the story focused on the main plot, which centers around Juliet’s father’s experiments, and the dangers they present to her and those around her–which is about as much as I’ll say–it actually became a bit of a page-turner. There were plenty of plot twists to keep me interested, too. So, not my favorite read, but not a complete shipwreck either.
What I’m Writing
I’m still working on edits to the first draft of the WIP. Nothing more to report, but I am pleased (and kind of excited) to see some people offering their beta reading services (see last week’s comments). Thank you all! If you want to be included on the list to beta read this novel when I get through with it, please let me know either in the comments or via email. My email address is on my About page, and you can get an idea of what my WIP is about from the WIP page. I’ll probably only select two or three readers, but everyone that expresses an interest encourages me to keep going.
The portion of my brain where ideas go to brew is currently working on a vampire story. This could be my NaNoWriMo project for the year, as it sounds like it could be an interesting, and perhaps novel approach to the genre. Some of you might be confused because you know I don’t generally read or write horror. But the idea hit me, and it’s proven too good of an idea to let go. More on this when there’s more to share!
What Inspires Me Right Now
Back to THE MADMAN’S DAUGHTER. As I indicated last time, this book has been inspirational in that it has made me think about things I shouldn’t do. The way Juliet responds to romance makes me give thought to my characters, and making sure their reactions are in-keeping with who they are, and not with preconceived genre conventions. Also, a couple of times Juliet uses language that I thought to be inappropriate for the period and her upbringing. The story is set in Victorian/Edwardian times, and the characters are either English, or have received an English upbringing. Once in the book, Juliet refers to something as having been “busted.” As a term for “broken,” I’ve only known it to be used in the US, or perhaps among British schoolkids (perhaps under the influence of US television). Seeing it on Juliet’s lips reminded me that the author is American. And when I’m reading a novel, I shouldn’t be reminded of the novel’s author. The author should be like Jim Henson. When you see Kermit the Frog on Sesame Street, you don’t look at him and think of Jim Henson. You look at him and see Kermit. If Kermit were to suddenly talk like Jim Henson, using his vocabulary and ideas, you’d realize something’s wrong, and the illusion would be broken. Something for me to keep in mind as I’m writing my alien girl. Also, along a similar line, there was a point in the story where Juliet indicates that 13-year-old girls should be thinking about first dates and first kisses. That may be so in today’s Western culture; but I’m not so sure about back then. I could be wrong, but as I recall, in Victorian times 13-year-olds wouldn’t be expected to worry about boys. They were considered children, and still some years away from being marriage material. And when that time came, she would have courted, not dated, and the courtship would have been with a view to marriage. Again, I might be wrong about this, but I think the broader point to bear in mind is for me to avoid assuming my characters share my cultural ideas and viewpoints–especially if I’m writing about a different time period, and/or an alien culture.
What Else I’ve Been Up To
I haven’t been up to much, but my SecondBorn has been on a trip to South East Asia, and if you know how much of an Asiaphile she is, you’ll know how exciting this was for her. Anyway, she returns today, so I’m looking forward to seeing her and hearing all her stories. Aside from that, not much else to report.
How have you been this week?
Sounds like you have a great day in store with your daughter! I’m sure she’ll have tons of stories 🙂
Glad to hear those revisions are going well. And definitely grab hold of those betas – they can be hard to come by. I’m currently working on a YA set in the 1850’s, so your comments on this book were interesting. Reminds me of things I’m going to have to watch out for.
My WIP is set in the later Victorian period (1879), which is just on the cusp of the electrical revolution–an important plot point for me. It can be very tricky navigating historical waters, especially when key story points hinge on a historical detail. But also giving verisimilitude–making the reader believe your story really does take place in that time period–depends on things like speech patterns, cultural references, these kinds of details that give the smell of Victoriana to the novel.
And yes, I will treasure each person who volunteers to give of their time to help make this novel better. 🙂
I love finding new beta readers via my blog, especially when they’re awesome blogging buddies and it sounds like you’re about to get a slew of wonderful readers! I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy THE MADMAN’S DAUGHTER, but it’s good that you can take a lot from it.
I hope you have a wonderful week!
It sounds a strange thing to say, but I’m looking forward to finishing revisions and handing the ms to beta readers. It’s not just being finished with my revisions, but getting feedback from others.
As for THE MADMAN’S DAUGHTER, I wouldn’t say I didn’t enjoy it, exactly. There were certainly things about it I didn’t like, and those tainted my view of the novel as a whole. But it did get better, and it wasn’t a tortuous experience reading to the end. In fact, I liked finding out how the story resolved.
I admire you for writing a historical book. Keeping the dialogue and the names and the locations as they should be must be so tricky. Best of luck with it, Colin!
Thanks, Cole. Sometimes I think I have a cruel imagination. After all, it’s hard enough writing from a first person female perspective when you aren’t female. Then to make that character from a different planet. And then put her in Victorian London. What was I thinking?! 🙂
We’ll see how it all turns out…
I enjoyed the plot twists in The Madman’s Daughter but I wasn’t a complete fan of the love triangle either. Once I finished the book it made sense but part of the time it just felt like it was there because that is what happens in YA books. Someone likes more than one person at the same time…. Some love triangles are interesting but they tend to be overdone.
Good luck on your writing!
That’s one of the things about the book that made me cringe. There’s such a lot of range and depth to the YA genre, no author should feel tied to a “template.” Not every teenage experience involves heavy romance and love triangles. Yes, many teens have an eye for the opposite sex–that’s hormones. But not all to the same degree, and not all in the same way, and not all the time in every circumstance! If I was stuck on an island in fear of my life, I don’t think I’d be spending too much time worrying about if some girl fancied me, and paying attention to her every move. And especially with *this* particular MC, I thought her preoccupation with the guys in the story was out-of-character.
Thanks, Sarah!
I love when I read something and it allows me to reflect on my own writing in ways I never knew were possible. Sometimes it takes finding a slight flaw in another story to help flesh out those in your own.
Enjoy your daughter’s return – I’ll bet she has some amazing stories to share!
No story is perfect, but I think every novel can teach an observant writer something that can help his or her writing. Which is one of the reasons I don’t like dismissing a book just because I don’t get into it, or it annoys me in the first few chapters.
Thanks, Erin! SecondBorn arrived home safely, full of stories to tell, and a heightened love of Asia. She definitely wants to go back.
Such interesting thoughts on THE MADMAN’S DAUGHTER. I haven’t read it yet but it’s been on my list for a while. I have to agree that I find it inspirational to see things in a book that I want to avoid. Obviously so much is subjective and one person might like what another doesn’t, but it’s sometimes easier to identify things you don’t like/want to avoid in someone else’s writing.
Good luck on your continued edits this week!
Thanks, Kip! Taste is subjective, and people can like books that even make huge technical snafoos (telling not showing, too much exposition, etc.), but there’s something to be learned from every novel we read. How can an author break “the rules” and still get away with writing a compelling novel? Why is it that I disliked the MC, but felt drawn to the story? For the writer, every novel is an education.
That’s probably the one pro I keep in mind when I’ve been disappointed by a book and felt a bit bummed: to remember what didn’t work for me. It’s why authors recommend budding authors to read all the time. Read the good and the bad to find what does and what doesn’t work for you.
I’ve been very interested in your WiP. It sounds great so if you need a beta, I’d try and do my best!
And you’ve already got me curious about the potential vampire WiP. You’ve turned to the dark side! =P
Cool!! Thanks for the offer to beta read. I’ll add you to the list. 🙂
LOL–I don’t know about turning to the dark side! Indeed, if I was to write horror out of a love of the genre, a vampire story wouldn’t have been my first choice. 🙂 However, the kernel of this story has been kicking around in my head for the last year, and it recently developed in an intriguing way. It may end up being rubbish, but I’m curious enough to at least do a first draft and see where it goes. And I want to do it for NaNo, which means I need to be done with the current WIP by November (I’m not working on both simultaneously). Hopefully I’ll be done with the current WIP well before then. 🙂
One thing that drives me up the wall is when authors use words that clearly aren’t right for the time/place. It seems like such a little thing, but it’s enough to take me out of the story. (One of my CPs is Australian and wrote a MS with an American MC – she actually sent it to me specifically to look for things like that.)
I’m way behind on people’s posts right now because I’m moving and Internet is spotty at my sublet, but I’m going to check out your WIP info now since everyone is so intrigued by it 🙂
Since I’m originally from the UK, I’m particularly sensitive to this issue (though I’ve been in the US long enough that I have to watch for it myself at times!). It doesn’t take a lot of effort to get dialog and culture right–choosing beta readers from that country is an excellent way of checking for inaccuracies.
I’m pleased and encouraged by how intrigued people are by my WIP. I hope I don’t disappoint… 🙂
I hope the move is going smoothly for you, Stephanie!
I’m a huge fan of vampire stories, not matter where they rank on the trending scale. It sounds like you have an interest in history, which will come in handy since your vampire will most likely come from a long ago time period. Have a fun reunion with your SecondBorn. Hope she took lots of pics!
Ooo–you’re a vampire story fan are you, Natasha? I’ll have to bear that in mind when I’m looking for beta readers for it, assuming it’s good enough to take that far. 🙂
She took 500+ pictures!! And while I’ve only heard a fraction of the stories, it sounds like she had a wonderful time. Thanks! 🙂
Ooh, horror! I’m too much of a chicken to even attempt to write something scary, although I did think about it years ago after having a creepy dream. Maybe I should pick it up again sometime b/c I still, crazily enough, remember a ton of details about the dream.
Good luck with your edits and enjoy your reunion with your daughter!
Maybe you should pick it up again, if only as an exercise for yourself–something you don’t normally write, just for practice and to stretch yourself. Especially if you still remember a lot of details.
Thanks, Jennifer–it’s been fun listening to her stories and reflections on the trip. 🙂
How exciting and lucky for your daughter!
Yes, sometimes we learn as much from what doesn’t work in a book as what does work. Analyzing WHY something doesn’t work is key.
Good luck and enjoy your daughter’s homecoming. 🙂
Thanks, Lola! Absolutely right about analyzing WHY something doesn’t work–at least why it doesn’t work for me. The first person that needs to love my novel is me–how can I sell it to an agent if I don’t like it? So I need to be sure I avoid all the things that annoy me in other books!
It’s good to hear your thoughts on Madman’s Daughter. It’s on my TBR list somewhere, but now I think I can safely give some other books more precedence. The potential sounds like its there. Plus, it’s great that the read has helped you in thinking about your own WIP.
Isn’t it funny how sometimes an idea will strike your fancy so much that you just have to write it – even when it’s out of your norm? I’ve yet to actually go out of my usual genre, but I’ve certainly been tempted!
As I’ve said, these are my thoughts on the book. I don’t want to turn people away from it, but I want others to be aware of what I didn’t like about it in the event they share my taste. Of course, you may have a completely different take.
I’m not averse to writing out of my norm. Perhaps I’m not totally sure what my “norm” is. I’m a fairly eclectic reader, so I’m willing to try anything–well, most things. I tend to write whatever genre the story is. What’s scarier than attempting a vampire book is the thought: what if I’m GOOD at it?!! :-O
I love your analysis on THE MADMAN’S DAUGHTER. It’s always so good to see *why* a book didn’t click with a person, and I loved the little reminders of the things that can turn a reader away. I think it ends up being a slightly weird juxtaposition for authors, though, too…getting lost in the story themselves as they create it, and yet having to pull back and play editor to the same material. Wow, now I’m reminded all over again how a good CP is a must.
I hope that portion of your brain continues to brew on that idea. 🙂 I’ve never been a fan of horror (or any vampire stories; sorry, Twilight), but I really enjoy hearing about the unique spin that authors create on genres or characters that I wouldn’t think to love. Good luck!
That’s certainly one of the hardest things about writing, IMO–exercising objective judgment over your own material. It’s next to impossible. You may love certain scenes for reasons that would escape most of your readers, and you may want to chop scenes that your readers would love. As you say, that’s where good beta readers and CPs are a God-send. 🙂
Yes, I do have what I consider to be a bit of a different spin on the vampire story (though I’m not very well-read in horror, so it might actually have been done to death!). However, the particular spin I want to take will have to be played very carefully. I know it won’t be easy to do well. But that appears to be the story of my writing so far. Look at my current WIP! 🙂